By Matt Reed and Ursula Wolfe-Rocca
The Flint Water Crisis is one of the most egregious examples of environmental racism in recent memory. In 2011, Michigan Governor Rick Snyder appointed an “emergency manager,” an unelected official, to oversee the majority-Black city’s budget and cut costs. To save money, the manager ended the city’s five-decade practice of piping treated water for its residents from Detroit, and opted to pump highly corrosive, untreated water from the Flint River. While residents immediately complained of skin rashes, hair loss, and foul smelling and tasting water, it took more than a year before the contaminated water was addressed by the government, and many more years of litigation and grassroots organizing to win a settlement for victims. At least a dozen people died of Legionnaires’ disease and many more were sickened with lead and other toxins.
“Water is Life” by Pete Railand from the Poor People’s Campaign portfolio via Justseeds
Flint is not anomalous. In every corner of the country poor people and people of color are disproportionately burdened by environmental contamination — in their neighborhoods, schools, and homes.
In this mixer activity, inspired by the 2016 Democracy Now! documentary Thirsty for Democracy, students learn about the struggle of residents to access safe water for drinking, cooking, and bathing in the majority-Black cities of Flint, Michigan; Jackson, Mississippi; and Newark, New Jersey. By bringing the circumstances of these locales into conversation with one another, students see that water crises are not simply accidents that could happen anywhere; they are manifestations of racism, past and present, that happen in some places — and to some people — far more than others. As Robert Bullard, known as the “father of environmental justice,” a scholar featured in the activity, says, “Zip code is still the most potent predictor of an individual’s health and well-being.”
In the mixer, each student takes on the persona of someone whose life is touched by these crises — along with some scholars and experts who offer important background — and hear stories from each other to surface patterns across the different cities. In conversations, they find others who can help answer mixer questions. For example: “Find someone who was directly affected or harmed by one of the water crises. Who are they? How were they affected or harmed?”
Students meet Kawanne Armstrong, a Flint grandmother who tested her water when it started running brown and smelling foul, and found it had dangerous levels of lead. Now she relies entirely on bottled water for herself and her grandson, which is not always easy to come by. Students meet Kehinde Gaynor, of Jackson, who explains the painful calculus of parenting through a water shutdown:
My daughter loves to eat fruit. She says, “Daddy, can I get an apple?” But rather than just grab one and give it to her, I’m weighing washing that apple off with the same bottle of water that we’re using to brush our teeth, to drink, to clean. Do I have enough water to give my daughter an apple?
Students also encounter stories of community activists. Shakima Thomas says that it was her 5-year-old testing positive for lead — a neurotoxin that can permanently damage children’s brains — that pushed her to join the Newark Water Coalition and lobby the city to replace the lead pipes. Nayyirah Shariff works with the Flint Democracy Defense League (FDDL), which organized a door-to-door campaign delivering bottled water, water filters, and replacement filters, and to document people’s stories about the water crisis.
Those on the frontlines also share their analysis of the roots of the crises. From Claire McClinton, founder of FDDL, students learn it was Flint’s unelected emergency manager, who sought to save money by switching Flint’s drinking water from the Detroit system to the poisonous Flint River, where General Motors had dumped industrial toxins for decades. She insists the Flint crisis is not only a water problem, but also “a democracy problem.” From Kendrick Hart in Jackson, students learn that one of two main water treatment plants in the city is more than 100 years old but that when Jackson is under a boil-water notice or water pressure is too low to flush a toilet or take a shower, the water systems in the majority-white suburbs continue to operate without problem.
The activity also includes a handful of “experts,” people neither residents of the cities, nor directly organizing on their behalf, but who share critical context about the systemic causes of the crises. From journalist Judd Legum, students learn that a massive multibillion dollar corporation — Siemens — brokered a $90 million contract with the city of Jackson to fix the water system, which it utterly failed to do. From hydroclimatologist Dr. Upmanu Lall, students learn that all parts of the U.S. municipal water system need massive upgrades and investment. But, he points out, while the United States has a Department of Energy (which continues to prop up the death-dealing fossil fuel industry), it has no Department of Water to coordinate the vast and critically important undertaking of ensuring clean water for the nation.
Ultimately, the stories included in this activity suggest that the injustices faced by the residents in Flint, Newark, and Jackson will not be addressed by merely swapping out pipes or building a new water treatment plant. There is a water crisis; but there is also a housing crisis, a health care crisis, a governance crisis, a funding crisis, and yes, a white supremacy and capitalism crisis. This activity helps students identify key causes of environmental racism so they are better equipped to demand and enact lasting solutions that will add up to a more just world for us all.
Roles for this lesson include:
- Kawanne Armstrong, Flint, Michigan, resident
- Dr. Mona Hanna-Attisha, Children’s Hospital of Michigan
- Ras Baraka, Mayor of Newark, New Jersey
- Sabre Bee, Newark Water Coalition
- Dr. Robert D. Bullard, Texas Southern University
- Christopher Daniels, Newark, New Jersey, resident
- Anthony Diaz, Newark Water Coalition
- Kenyetta Dotson, Flint, Michigan, resident
- Kehinde Gaynor, Jackson, Mississippi, resident
- Kendrick Hart, Jackson, Mississippi, resident
- Kali Akuno, Jackson, Mississippi, Cooperation Jackson
- Yvette Jordan, Newark Education Workers Caucus
- Dr. Upmanu Lall, Columbia University
- Haley Lane, University of California, Berkeley
- Judd Legum, Journalist
- Mayor Chokwe A. Lumumba, Jackson, Mississippi
- Larry Marshall, Flint, Michigan, resident
- Melissa Mays, Water You Fighting For and Flint, Michigan, resident
- Claire McClinton, Flint Democracy Defense League
- Ivelisse Mincey, Newark, New Jersey, resident
- Paul Mohai, University of Michigan School for Environment and Sustainability
- Erik Olson, National Resource Defense Council
- Dr. Aaron Packman, Center for Water Research
- Pauline Rogers, RECH Foundation, Jackson, Mississippi
- Nayyirah Shariff, Flint Democracy Defense League (FDDL) and Flint Rising
- Shakima Thomas, Newark Water Coalition and Newark, New Jersey, resident
Matt Reed teaches high school social studies in Portland, Oregon. He is a co-editor of the forthcoming second edition of the Rethinking Schools teaching guide, A People’s Curriculum for the Earth. Read more.
Ursula Wolfe-Rocca has taught high school social studies since 2000. Ursula works full time for the Zinn Education Project and is on the editorial board of Rethinking Schools magazine. She has written articles and lessons on voting rights, redlining, deportations, COINTELPRO, climate justice, Red Summer, the Cold War, and more. Read more.
This lesson was featured in the spring 2023 issue of Rethinking Schools magazine and will be in the second edition of the Rethinking Schools teaching guide, A People’s Curriculum for the Earth.
Classroom Stories
I super enjoyed using the Water and Environmental Racism lesson. I included all of the resources provided in the download and added a few additional resources, which fit perfectly within the content of my African American Studies course.
My class is a bit on the quieter side and the mixer not only provided them with interesting reading material, but encouraged students to walk around the room, ask each other questions, and truly engage with one another. I thought it was particularly special that each role in the mixer was based on a real person, and I was sure to emphasize that to my students. Knowing that information made the discussion more powerful.
The students found this lesson to be powerful and alarming, and their reactions at the end indicated that they will now reconsider the many ways in which their physical health is connected to their physical environment and literal place in the world.
I will definitely use this lesson again.
The Water and Environmental Racism lesson was a huge help in engaging my students with an interactive lesson in honor of Earth Day!
Many of my seniors this year are exceptionally passionate about the environment and about equity, so this lesson was right up their alley. Some of the class members who are typically less interested in topics of equity became quite engaged in the lesson because of the personal testimonies; they truly empathized with the people they portrayed. It’s hard to get seniors out of their seats and animated, but your lesson did just that.
Finally, I really appreciated that the resource included questions and personal testimony from people who took constructive action. This avoided the single narrative of victimization and enabled me to reinforce to students that, even though injustice occurs, regular citizens — though we don’t often see them or know their names — take action to raise awareness and correct the inequity. The point of learning about these outrageous events is not to simply observe misery and to despair, but to be informed and observant, to learn from strategies we encountered in this lesson, and to advocate for equity.
We used the Water and Environmental Racism lesson about Flint, Jackson, and Newark, to explore geography, looking at how cultural features and physical features interact with each other to think about our essential question, “Why does where matter?” By looking at these three case studies, we were able to determine that where does matter, and it can have a positive or negative impact on your lived experiences. We also looked at how humans impact the physical features around them, such as water. By looking at cultural features and physical features, we could look at the impact of humans on the world around them.
We took this lesson and also applied it to the concept of migration to explore push and pull factors. Some people are pushed to migrate by circumstances and some people are pulled. We thought about the options for citizens of Newark, Flint, and Jackson and if they would be pushed, pulled, or if they might decide to stay and take action. This also allowed us to think about who was responsible for the water crisis and who were people that might be able to effect change.
I am a professor of environmental studies and used the Water and Environmental Racism lesson in my class during our week on environmental justice. Students immediately took to this lesson, and I was pleased to see that some less talkative students in class really got into portraying their character roles with compassion. This was especially the case with character roles who had young children, and students passionately relayed the injustice of having to choose between brushing one’s teeth or giving their child water. Other students whose roles were academics or researchers interjected how much they wanted to help their communities by providing information or resources.
After the role play, students made connections between government accountability, class, race, and even presidential elections, geography, and deindustrialization in Michigan. Some students even added anecdotal experiences with temporary water shortages in their neighborhoods. I highly recommend this activity for introductory-level college classes. I also recommend participating in the activity if you can, and hearing how students embody their roles.
The Water and Environmental Racism lesson helps young people grapple with how racism shows up in our everyday lives. It allows students to engage with the stories of people fighting against environmental racism and helps them understand how they can play a role.
Students love hearing the everyday stories of people fighting for racial, social, and environmental justice, and it gives them hope for a different future that is good for all people.
Twitter
Google plus
LinkedIn